Ganesh Trading Journal
- immy
- Founder
- Posts: 9654
- Joined: 22 Nov 2010, 16:46
- 14
Re: Ganesh Trading Journal
GREAT analysis... you're becoming a Trader... gradually...
What is the Secret of Successful Trading?
The Consistent Pursuit of DS1
The thing that makes me money in trading is when I "Objectively Follow my Trading Plan".
I understand that I can't catch all the moves or all the signals but my objective is to catch THE VALID SIGNALS & ONLY the Valid Signals.
My Deathbed Advice "5:1 Reward to Risk Ratio".
Yo, banana boy!
The Consistent Pursuit of DS1

The thing that makes me money in trading is when I "Objectively Follow my Trading Plan".
I understand that I can't catch all the moves or all the signals but my objective is to catch THE VALID SIGNALS & ONLY the Valid Signals.
My Deathbed Advice "5:1 Reward to Risk Ratio".
Yo, banana boy!
-
- Free Member
- Posts: 182
- Joined: 07 Apr 2019, 08:25
- 6
Re: Ganesh Trading Journal
Thanks Immy, Step by Step:
1. Trade Number: 5/20 Batch 2
2. Date/Time: 21/01/2020 - Morning Session
3. Symbol/TF: Dax/1m
4. Signal Type / Direction: Short
5. Comments and Feelings at the Time of Taking The Trade: Price broke at heaviliy at LO and retraced back; price had steam behind it and I saw this Seed. I was concerned about the M5 support on the left hand side but figured that there was still a good chance for a 2:1.
6.Comments and Trades After Exiting the Trade: Price kind of did what I expected... and missed my TP by a 1pt.
7. DS For this Trade: 5DS
8. DS Running Total: 100% (4/20) (5DS1 & 0DS0)
9. Result: 0R
10: Badge R: 2R (Target 10)
11. Screenshot:
1. Trade Number: 5/20 Batch 2
2. Date/Time: 21/01/2020 - Morning Session
3. Symbol/TF: Dax/1m
4. Signal Type / Direction: Short
5. Comments and Feelings at the Time of Taking The Trade: Price broke at heaviliy at LO and retraced back; price had steam behind it and I saw this Seed. I was concerned about the M5 support on the left hand side but figured that there was still a good chance for a 2:1.
6.Comments and Trades After Exiting the Trade: Price kind of did what I expected... and missed my TP by a 1pt.
7. DS For this Trade: 5DS
8. DS Running Total: 100% (4/20) (5DS1 & 0DS0)
9. Result: 0R
10: Badge R: 2R (Target 10)
11. Screenshot:
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.
-
- Free Member
- Posts: 182
- Joined: 07 Apr 2019, 08:25
- 6
Re: Ganesh Trading Journal
Thanks Immy, Step by Step:
1. Trade Number: 6/20 Batch 2
2. Date/Time: 22/01/2020 - Morning Session
3. Symbol/TF: Dax/1m
4. Signal Type / Direction: Long Seed
5. Comments and Feelings at the Time of Taking The Trade: Price broke nicely out of a range and then formed a Seed. I got in; felt confident.
6.Comments and Trades After Exiting the Trade: Price missed my BE just by 1 Point and I ended up with a loss; felt frustrated; if ATM didn't have my Buffers it would have been a BE; so I changed my buffer setting to 0; this has now happened a few times; let's see how this setting goes. Jasmin then also pointed out that Gator was not open and in reality the trade hasn't established. As I missed it, it's a DS0. Also feeling a bit frustrated with the market in Jan; Dax not moving and a lot of sideways...
7. DS For this Trade: 0DS
8. DS Running Total: 83% (6/20) (5DS1 & 1DS0)
9. Result: -1R
10: Badge R: 1R (Target 10)
11. Screenshot:
1. Trade Number: 6/20 Batch 2
2. Date/Time: 22/01/2020 - Morning Session
3. Symbol/TF: Dax/1m
4. Signal Type / Direction: Long Seed
5. Comments and Feelings at the Time of Taking The Trade: Price broke nicely out of a range and then formed a Seed. I got in; felt confident.
6.Comments and Trades After Exiting the Trade: Price missed my BE just by 1 Point and I ended up with a loss; felt frustrated; if ATM didn't have my Buffers it would have been a BE; so I changed my buffer setting to 0; this has now happened a few times; let's see how this setting goes. Jasmin then also pointed out that Gator was not open and in reality the trade hasn't established. As I missed it, it's a DS0. Also feeling a bit frustrated with the market in Jan; Dax not moving and a lot of sideways...
7. DS For this Trade: 0DS
8. DS Running Total: 83% (6/20) (5DS1 & 1DS0)
9. Result: -1R
10: Badge R: 1R (Target 10)
11. Screenshot:
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.
-
- Free Member
- Posts: 182
- Joined: 07 Apr 2019, 08:25
- 6
Re: Ganesh Trading Journal
1. Trade Number: 7/20 Batch 2
2. Date/Time: 24/01/2020 - Morning Session
3. Symbol/TF: Dax/1m
4. Signal Type / Direction: Long Seed
5. Comments and Feelings at the Time of Taking The Trade: Price broke out of M5, beautiful range and trend; market had momentum; beautiful Seed!
6.Comments and Trades After Exiting the Trade: BE, but then price went and exploded; frustrating but part of the experience; I also experienced a lot of nervousness watching the trade, hoping it will break; loads of emotions involved for just watching the chart; need to watch work on that!
7. DS For this Trade: 1DS
8. DS Running Total: 86% (7/20) (6DS1 & 1DS0)
9. Result: 0
10: Badge R: 1R (Target 10)
11. Screenshot: 1. Trade Number: 8/20 Batch 2
2. Date/Time: 24/01/2020 - Morning Session
3. Symbol/TF: Dax/1m
4. Signal Type / Direction: Long S1
5. Comments and Feelings at the Time of Taking The Trade:Market peaked after the big momentum spike early price peaked and i saw the formation of an S1. It had a green dot as price closed slightly outside the tight box.
6.Comments and Trades After Exiting the Trade: Price moved a bit higher, ranged for a while and stopped me out; didn't have proper momentum; perhaps I need to have the same consideration as for the hunt and only enter if there is momentum for S1 in the market,
7. DS For this Trade: 1DS
8. DS Running Total: 88% (8/20) (7DS1 & 1DS0)
9. Result: -1R
10: Badge R: 0R (Target 10)
11. Screenshot:
2. Date/Time: 24/01/2020 - Morning Session
3. Symbol/TF: Dax/1m
4. Signal Type / Direction: Long Seed
5. Comments and Feelings at the Time of Taking The Trade: Price broke out of M5, beautiful range and trend; market had momentum; beautiful Seed!
6.Comments and Trades After Exiting the Trade: BE, but then price went and exploded; frustrating but part of the experience; I also experienced a lot of nervousness watching the trade, hoping it will break; loads of emotions involved for just watching the chart; need to watch work on that!
7. DS For this Trade: 1DS
8. DS Running Total: 86% (7/20) (6DS1 & 1DS0)
9. Result: 0
10: Badge R: 1R (Target 10)
11. Screenshot: 1. Trade Number: 8/20 Batch 2
2. Date/Time: 24/01/2020 - Morning Session
3. Symbol/TF: Dax/1m
4. Signal Type / Direction: Long S1
5. Comments and Feelings at the Time of Taking The Trade:Market peaked after the big momentum spike early price peaked and i saw the formation of an S1. It had a green dot as price closed slightly outside the tight box.
6.Comments and Trades After Exiting the Trade: Price moved a bit higher, ranged for a while and stopped me out; didn't have proper momentum; perhaps I need to have the same consideration as for the hunt and only enter if there is momentum for S1 in the market,
7. DS For this Trade: 1DS
8. DS Running Total: 88% (8/20) (7DS1 & 1DS0)
9. Result: -1R
10: Badge R: 0R (Target 10)
11. Screenshot:
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.
-
- Free Member
- Posts: 182
- Joined: 07 Apr 2019, 08:25
- 6
Re: Ganesh Trading Journal
1. Trade Number: 9/20 Batch 2
2. Date/Time: 28/01/2020 - Morning Session
3. Symbol/TF: Dax/1m
4. Signal Type / Direction: Short Seed
5. Comments and Feelings at the Time of Taking The Trade: Market started trending after breaking the M5 resistance area; seed formed and I went short...
6.Comments and Trades After Exiting the Trade: I tried a new setting on the ATM with 0 buffer and it stopped me out straightaway; it should have been a BE trade; i've now put my buffer for 1pt entries and 2pt stop loss...
7. DS For this Trade: 1DS
8. DS Running Total: 88% (9/20) (8DS1 & 1DS0)
9. Result: -2R
10: Badge R: -2R (Target 10)
11. Screenshot:
1. Trade Number: 10/20 Batch 2
2. Date/Time: 28/01/2020 - Morning Session
3. Symbol/TF: Dax/1m
4. Signal Type / Direction: Short S1
5. Comments and Feelings at the Time of Taking The Trade: After the M5 range breakout price was on a move; beautiful setup happened and I took it.
6.Comments and Trades After Exiting the Trade: Trade ended up being a BE BUT I didn't check that TZ1 was smaller than 2:1; so even though it was a beautiful setup, according to my rules I shouldn't have taken it.
7. DS For this Trade: 0DS
8. DS Running Total: 80% (9/20) (8DS1 & 2DS0)
9. Result: -2R
10: Badge R: -2R (Target 10)
11. Screenshot:
2. Date/Time: 28/01/2020 - Morning Session
3. Symbol/TF: Dax/1m
4. Signal Type / Direction: Short Seed
5. Comments and Feelings at the Time of Taking The Trade: Market started trending after breaking the M5 resistance area; seed formed and I went short...
6.Comments and Trades After Exiting the Trade: I tried a new setting on the ATM with 0 buffer and it stopped me out straightaway; it should have been a BE trade; i've now put my buffer for 1pt entries and 2pt stop loss...
7. DS For this Trade: 1DS
8. DS Running Total: 88% (9/20) (8DS1 & 1DS0)
9. Result: -2R
10: Badge R: -2R (Target 10)
11. Screenshot:
1. Trade Number: 10/20 Batch 2
2. Date/Time: 28/01/2020 - Morning Session
3. Symbol/TF: Dax/1m
4. Signal Type / Direction: Short S1
5. Comments and Feelings at the Time of Taking The Trade: After the M5 range breakout price was on a move; beautiful setup happened and I took it.
6.Comments and Trades After Exiting the Trade: Trade ended up being a BE BUT I didn't check that TZ1 was smaller than 2:1; so even though it was a beautiful setup, according to my rules I shouldn't have taken it.
7. DS For this Trade: 0DS
8. DS Running Total: 80% (9/20) (8DS1 & 2DS0)
9. Result: -2R
10: Badge R: -2R (Target 10)
11. Screenshot:
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.
-
- Free Member
- Posts: 182
- Joined: 07 Apr 2019, 08:25
- 6
Re: Ganesh Trading Journal
1. Trade Number: 11/20 Batch 2
2. Date/Time: 28/01/2020 - Morning Session
3. Symbol/TF: Dax/1m
4. Signal Type / Direction: Long Seed
5. Comments and Feelings at the Time of Taking The Trade: Price broke out of a nice range and formed a cherry, followed by a seed. I triple checked all the rules in my head and went in.
6.Comments and Trades After Exiting the Trade: Price went for a nice 2:1; however whilst I was in the trade I was nervous; especially when price didn't break out straight away and went stuck for a few bars; internally I was nervous and worried whether this could be another loss. I need to work on that!
7. DS For this Trade: 1DS
8. DS Running Total: 82% (9/20) (9DS1 & 2DS0)
9. Result: 2R
10: Badge R: 0R (Target 10)
11. Screenshot:
2. Date/Time: 28/01/2020 - Morning Session
3. Symbol/TF: Dax/1m
4. Signal Type / Direction: Long Seed
5. Comments and Feelings at the Time of Taking The Trade: Price broke out of a nice range and formed a cherry, followed by a seed. I triple checked all the rules in my head and went in.
6.Comments and Trades After Exiting the Trade: Price went for a nice 2:1; however whilst I was in the trade I was nervous; especially when price didn't break out straight away and went stuck for a few bars; internally I was nervous and worried whether this could be another loss. I need to work on that!
7. DS For this Trade: 1DS
8. DS Running Total: 82% (9/20) (9DS1 & 2DS0)
9. Result: 2R
10: Badge R: 0R (Target 10)
11. Screenshot:
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.
-
- Free Member
- Posts: 182
- Joined: 07 Apr 2019, 08:25
- 6
Re: Ganesh Trading Journal
NEVER TRADE WHEN IM ILL AND ON MEDICATION...
1. Trade Number: 12/20 Batch 2
2. Date/Time: 31/01/2020 - Morning Session
3. Symbol/TF: Dax/1m
4. Signal Type / Direction: Short Seed
5. Comments and Feelings at the Time of Taking The Trade: Mind wasn't clearly; I was on codeine to deal with stomach pain; I felt guilty not trading; when I was looking at the charts, I felt nervous, anxious not clear in my mind. Saw a trade and took it...
6.Comments and Trades After Exiting the Trade: I don't want to go in the analysis of the trade; market wasn't moving...etc... but I shouldn't have taken this trade with a clouded mind...
7. DS For this Trade: 0DS
8. DS Running Total: 75% (12/20) (9DS1 & 3DS0)
9. Result: -1R
10: Badge R: -1R (Target 10)
11. Screenshot:
1. Trade Number: 12/20 Batch 2
2. Date/Time: 31/01/2020 - Morning Session
3. Symbol/TF: Dax/1m
4. Signal Type / Direction: Short Seed
5. Comments and Feelings at the Time of Taking The Trade: Mind wasn't clearly; I was on codeine to deal with stomach pain; I felt guilty not trading; when I was looking at the charts, I felt nervous, anxious not clear in my mind. Saw a trade and took it...
6.Comments and Trades After Exiting the Trade: I don't want to go in the analysis of the trade; market wasn't moving...etc... but I shouldn't have taken this trade with a clouded mind...
7. DS For this Trade: 0DS
8. DS Running Total: 75% (12/20) (9DS1 & 3DS0)
9. Result: -1R
10: Badge R: -1R (Target 10)
11. Screenshot:
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.
-
- Free Member
- Posts: 182
- Joined: 07 Apr 2019, 08:25
- 6
Re: Ganesh Trading Journal
1. Trade Number: 13/20 Batch 2
2. Date/Time: 03/02/2020 - AFternoon Session
3. Symbol/TF: Dax/1m
4. Signal Type / Direction: Long Seed
5. Comments and Feelings at the Time of Taking The Trade: Nothing at Dax open, had time at NEO open so was checking what's going on; price went higher and went out of a range and formed a seed. I took it.
6.Comments and Trades After Exiting the Trade: I'm not saying that I have understood everything, but becomes clear to me is to trade when the market moves; this normally happens at LO or NEO and you will know when the price moves; + if it breaks a range, then it's a good nvironment to look for signal
7. DS For this Trade: 1DS
8. DS Running Total: 77% (13/20) (10DS1 & 3DS0)
9. Result: 2R
10: Badge R: +1R (Target 10)
11. Screenshot:
2. Date/Time: 03/02/2020 - AFternoon Session
3. Symbol/TF: Dax/1m
4. Signal Type / Direction: Long Seed
5. Comments and Feelings at the Time of Taking The Trade: Nothing at Dax open, had time at NEO open so was checking what's going on; price went higher and went out of a range and formed a seed. I took it.
6.Comments and Trades After Exiting the Trade: I'm not saying that I have understood everything, but becomes clear to me is to trade when the market moves; this normally happens at LO or NEO and you will know when the price moves; + if it breaks a range, then it's a good nvironment to look for signal
7. DS For this Trade: 1DS
8. DS Running Total: 77% (13/20) (10DS1 & 3DS0)
9. Result: 2R
10: Badge R: +1R (Target 10)
11. Screenshot:
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.
-
- Free Member
- Posts: 182
- Joined: 07 Apr 2019, 08:25
- 6
Re: Ganesh Trading Journal
1. Trade Number: 14/20 Batch 2
2. Date/Time: 04/02/2020 - Morning Session
3. Symbol/TF: Dax/1m
4. Signal Type / Direction: Long Seed
5. Comments and Feelings at the Time of Taking The Trade: Literally same setup as previous just formed on the Dax M1 Morning Session. I got it in.
6.Comments and Trades After Exiting the Trade: Price got me a nice 2R. My emotions were flying high; I quickly learned to deal with my winners the same as with my loosers. Have a I stuck to my rules, Yes, then move on to the next one.
7. DS For this Trade: 1DS
8. DS Running Total: 79% (14/20) (11DS1 & 3DS0)
9. Result: 2R
10: Badge R: +3R (Target 10)
11. Screenshot: 1. Trade Number: 15/20 Batch 2
2. Date/Time: 04/02/2020 - Morning Session
3. Symbol/TF: Dax/1m
4. Signal Type / Direction: Long S1
5. Comments and Feelings at the Time of Taking The Trade: After the Seed, I was ready to finish but saw S1 perfectly setting up; the volume and energy out of the market seemed out but perfect setup and I got in.
6.Comments and Trades After Exiting the Trade: I got out at BE; one thing with these S1 when the market is not moving that quickly anymore is to protect your losses and move to BE as quickly as possible if price gets close to 1R BE... price then went up again and eventually to TZ1 but that would have taken ages... Also the more I trade the more I learn about myself; I prefer the Seed; it's a quick in and out... that's who I am and my style.
7. DS For this Trade: 1DS
8. DS Running Total: 80% (15/20) (12DS1 & 3DS0)
9. Result: 0R
10: Badge R: +3R (Target 10)
11. Screenshot: 1. Trade Number: 16/20 Batch 2
2. Date/Time: 04/02/2020 - Afternoon Session
3. Symbol/TF: Dax/1m
4. Signal Type / Direction: Long Seed
5. Comments and Feelings at the Time of Taking The Trade: Price broke the M5 range, seed formed I got in.
6.Comments and Trades After Exiting the Trade: Sellers won, price didn't break the highs. After the loss, I was trying to figure out reasons why it was a loss; then it clicked, nothing was wrong, it's part of the game baby. NEXT.
7. DS For this Trade: 1DS
8. DS Running Total: 81% (16/20) (13DS1 & 3DS0)
9. Result: -1R
10: Badge R: +2R (Target 10)
11. Screenshot:
2. Date/Time: 04/02/2020 - Morning Session
3. Symbol/TF: Dax/1m
4. Signal Type / Direction: Long Seed
5. Comments and Feelings at the Time of Taking The Trade: Literally same setup as previous just formed on the Dax M1 Morning Session. I got it in.
6.Comments and Trades After Exiting the Trade: Price got me a nice 2R. My emotions were flying high; I quickly learned to deal with my winners the same as with my loosers. Have a I stuck to my rules, Yes, then move on to the next one.
7. DS For this Trade: 1DS
8. DS Running Total: 79% (14/20) (11DS1 & 3DS0)
9. Result: 2R
10: Badge R: +3R (Target 10)
11. Screenshot: 1. Trade Number: 15/20 Batch 2
2. Date/Time: 04/02/2020 - Morning Session
3. Symbol/TF: Dax/1m
4. Signal Type / Direction: Long S1
5. Comments and Feelings at the Time of Taking The Trade: After the Seed, I was ready to finish but saw S1 perfectly setting up; the volume and energy out of the market seemed out but perfect setup and I got in.
6.Comments and Trades After Exiting the Trade: I got out at BE; one thing with these S1 when the market is not moving that quickly anymore is to protect your losses and move to BE as quickly as possible if price gets close to 1R BE... price then went up again and eventually to TZ1 but that would have taken ages... Also the more I trade the more I learn about myself; I prefer the Seed; it's a quick in and out... that's who I am and my style.
7. DS For this Trade: 1DS
8. DS Running Total: 80% (15/20) (12DS1 & 3DS0)
9. Result: 0R
10: Badge R: +3R (Target 10)
11. Screenshot: 1. Trade Number: 16/20 Batch 2
2. Date/Time: 04/02/2020 - Afternoon Session
3. Symbol/TF: Dax/1m
4. Signal Type / Direction: Long Seed
5. Comments and Feelings at the Time of Taking The Trade: Price broke the M5 range, seed formed I got in.
6.Comments and Trades After Exiting the Trade: Sellers won, price didn't break the highs. After the loss, I was trying to figure out reasons why it was a loss; then it clicked, nothing was wrong, it's part of the game baby. NEXT.
7. DS For this Trade: 1DS
8. DS Running Total: 81% (16/20) (13DS1 & 3DS0)
9. Result: -1R
10: Badge R: +2R (Target 10)
11. Screenshot:
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.
-
- Free Member
- Posts: 182
- Joined: 07 Apr 2019, 08:25
- 6
Re: Ganesh Trading Journal
No trades for me today but I learned:
- 1.S1: if box too big, wait for new fractal which doesn't break high of blue dot box and enter
2.S1 on M1 needs to correspond to Hunt Setup on M5
3.Check M5 to see ranges clearly and wait until price breaks out those ranges
4. Read price action well to understand potential impulses building up
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.