Herbert's trades for discussion
- immy
- Founder
- Posts: 9654
- Joined: 22 Nov 2010, 16:46
- 14
Re: Herbert's trades for discussion
Nice Post Herbert as usual!
I'd just like to say one thing.
" Everyone who looks for anything finds what they are looking for, that's why statistics (backtesting) are so amusing. "
This might on the face appear out of context or something but in its core, imo it isn't.
Chaos allows us to be at a point where the universe gives us the opportunity to choose from the infinite possibilities, one to create our own reality.
I'd just like to say one thing.
" Everyone who looks for anything finds what they are looking for, that's why statistics (backtesting) are so amusing. "
This might on the face appear out of context or something but in its core, imo it isn't.
Chaos allows us to be at a point where the universe gives us the opportunity to choose from the infinite possibilities, one to create our own reality.
What is the Secret of Successful Trading?
The Consistent Pursuit of DS1
The thing that makes me money in trading is when I "Objectively Follow my Trading Plan".
I understand that I can't catch all the moves or all the signals but my objective is to catch THE VALID SIGNALS & ONLY the Valid Signals.
My Deathbed Advice "5:1 Reward to Risk Ratio".
Yo, banana boy!
The Consistent Pursuit of DS1

The thing that makes me money in trading is when I "Objectively Follow my Trading Plan".
I understand that I can't catch all the moves or all the signals but my objective is to catch THE VALID SIGNALS & ONLY the Valid Signals.
My Deathbed Advice "5:1 Reward to Risk Ratio".
Yo, banana boy!
- snorm
- AIMSter
- Posts: 305
- Joined: 13 Aug 2011, 22:57
- 14
- Herbert
- Free Member
- Posts: 587
- Joined: 07 Jan 2012, 12:18
- 13
Re: Herbert's trades for discussion
Very true Immy. A huge trap in back-testing..B-)
You got it Steve
B-)
)
You got it Steve

B-)


Luck = LABOR UNDER CORRECT KNOWLEDGE - Forex Joe
"Nothing wins more than superior research and preparation"
AIMS - The art of Trading markets successfully
"Nothing wins more than superior research and preparation"
AIMS - The art of Trading markets successfully
- Herbert
- Free Member
- Posts: 587
- Joined: 07 Jan 2012, 12:18
- 13
Re: Herbert's trades for discussion
Hey Steve :-B
I have found this resource for some nice mql tools. Between these also an MT4 <>Excel data link to transport custom indicator data.
ExcelLINK ADDON Features:
Written in C++ to have optimal speed
Using Microsoft Native API to make the addon compatible with almost all versions of Excel
Send/Receive String/Value/Float values to/from Excel with simple commands
Capability to format cells fontsize, color
Capability to optionally autofit cells
Loading and Saving excel compatible files through Addon
Capability to send calculation commands like =sum(a1+a2)
Rename Sheets for better overview via commands
Supports sheets for all operations. Its possible to send output, read input or calculate on specified sheet
Free of charge
Thought you might be interested...
I am attempting to have my TradePlan, entry and exit rules written in Excel with indicator trigger data displayed next to it... =p~ Looking to get this working by 2017.. (rofl)
https://www.fx1.net" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;
I have found this resource for some nice mql tools. Between these also an MT4 <>Excel data link to transport custom indicator data.
ExcelLINK ADDON Features:
Written in C++ to have optimal speed
Using Microsoft Native API to make the addon compatible with almost all versions of Excel
Send/Receive String/Value/Float values to/from Excel with simple commands
Capability to format cells fontsize, color
Capability to optionally autofit cells
Loading and Saving excel compatible files through Addon
Capability to send calculation commands like =sum(a1+a2)
Rename Sheets for better overview via commands
Supports sheets for all operations. Its possible to send output, read input or calculate on specified sheet
Free of charge
Thought you might be interested...
I am attempting to have my TradePlan, entry and exit rules written in Excel with indicator trigger data displayed next to it... =p~ Looking to get this working by 2017.. (rofl)
https://www.fx1.net" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.
Luck = LABOR UNDER CORRECT KNOWLEDGE - Forex Joe
"Nothing wins more than superior research and preparation"
AIMS - The art of Trading markets successfully
"Nothing wins more than superior research and preparation"
AIMS - The art of Trading markets successfully
- Herbert
- Free Member
- Posts: 587
- Joined: 07 Jan 2012, 12:18
- 13
Re: Herbert's trades for discussion
I just had to post this one.
) Hello eurusd!!!
I show AIMS trend reversal, not providing a setup 1 BUT setup 2 variation. thus, no fresh AO ZL, alligator green tested (dimension 2). I went bit earlier than aims level break using 1st AO positive bar after alligator test....
Look at the new generation cross-over...
) Blue balance crossing purple and throw a trendline in while we are at it. B-)
TP area was planned for the 78.6 blue fib area with tight stops being hit on 2nd half of position. The fibs i draw is serving me well using a consistent method, no subjectivity. I am willing to share that if any-one interested. Just remember we are not target traders, just an old habit of mine...
NOTE: It has come to my attention that i was totally ignoring 2nd setups as it's own entity. Any thoughts on that?? Main difference is, no AO ZL... I am open to criticism. Let go people, i can take it..
Herbert

I show AIMS trend reversal, not providing a setup 1 BUT setup 2 variation. thus, no fresh AO ZL, alligator green tested (dimension 2). I went bit earlier than aims level break using 1st AO positive bar after alligator test....
Look at the new generation cross-over...

TP area was planned for the 78.6 blue fib area with tight stops being hit on 2nd half of position. The fibs i draw is serving me well using a consistent method, no subjectivity. I am willing to share that if any-one interested. Just remember we are not target traders, just an old habit of mine...
NOTE: It has come to my attention that i was totally ignoring 2nd setups as it's own entity. Any thoughts on that?? Main difference is, no AO ZL... I am open to criticism. Let go people, i can take it..

Herbert
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.
Luck = LABOR UNDER CORRECT KNOWLEDGE - Forex Joe
"Nothing wins more than superior research and preparation"
AIMS - The art of Trading markets successfully
"Nothing wins more than superior research and preparation"
AIMS - The art of Trading markets successfully
- Herbert
- Free Member
- Posts: 587
- Joined: 07 Jan 2012, 12:18
- 13
Re: Herbert's trades for discussion
W5 to suit..
Overstayed my welcome towards TZ1, w5 AO doing heavy breathing down the balance and channel line..
SL hit.
Overstayed my welcome towards TZ1, w5 AO doing heavy breathing down the balance and channel line..

You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.
Luck = LABOR UNDER CORRECT KNOWLEDGE - Forex Joe
"Nothing wins more than superior research and preparation"
AIMS - The art of Trading markets successfully
"Nothing wins more than superior research and preparation"
AIMS - The art of Trading markets successfully
- snorm
- AIMSter
- Posts: 305
- Joined: 13 Aug 2011, 22:57
- 14
Re: Herbert's trades for discussion
Looks interesting Herbert - thanks for sharing :-BHerbert wrote:Hey Steve :-B
I have found this resource for some nice mql tools. Between these also an MT4 <>Excel data link to transport custom indicator data.
ExcelLINK ADDON Features:
Written in C++ to have optimal speed
Using Microsoft Native API to make the addon compatible with almost all versions of Excel
Send/Receive String/Value/Float values to/from Excel with simple commands
Capability to format cells fontsize, color
Capability to optionally autofit cells
Loading and Saving excel compatible files through Addon
Capability to send calculation commands like =sum(a1+a2)
Rename Sheets for better overview via commands
Supports sheets for all operations. Its possible to send output, read input or calculate on specified sheet
Free of charge
Thought you might be interested...
I am attempting to have my TradePlan, entry and exit rules written in Excel with indicator trigger data displayed next to it... =p~ Looking to get this working by 2017.. (rofl)
https://www.fx1.net" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;
5 years to do a trading plan ? I've been working on mine for the last 10 years (rofl)
- Herbert
- Free Member
- Posts: 587
- Joined: 07 Jan 2012, 12:18
- 13
Re: Herbert's trades for discussion
Hey Steve :-B
I am posting here since i do not want to clutter the 5-wave thread and this post is dished straight-up, just add own salt...
)
As per my attached 1000 words, this morning's eurusd 1min, we had a wave 5 +divergence construction of lesser quality. (ZL not crossed).
Please check my thinking and excuse my different colours. I used the blue channel line to delineate 5 top exhaustion and resulting 1st TL break.
2nd red TL then sync's with break of purple.
Q1: Is your optimized/high probability qualifier for w4 a break of ZL or would this example be in your options since AO probably reached some-one's yellow minimum.
Q2: Since i do not want to do divergence trading as it's own setup and stay as close to AIMS principles as possible.
I have 3 possible entry scenario's. Your comments?
1. 1st TL break (blue, marked 1) and break+test of balance line.
2. 2nd break of TL and test of purple.
3. Break of aims level, setup 2.
I do realise 1min may have considerable variations because of it's subjected TF, above just guidelines.
No concern required from you, just putting you on the spot, gleaning your insights... :-B .. I take my own decisions.. B-)
Thanks for your valued time.
I am deliberating sending you some vetkoek-on-the-house to speed up the testing..... this chart scanning is making me crazy...
)
Herbert

I am posting here since i do not want to clutter the 5-wave thread and this post is dished straight-up, just add own salt...

As per my attached 1000 words, this morning's eurusd 1min, we had a wave 5 +divergence construction of lesser quality. (ZL not crossed).
Please check my thinking and excuse my different colours. I used the blue channel line to delineate 5 top exhaustion and resulting 1st TL break.
2nd red TL then sync's with break of purple.
Q1: Is your optimized/high probability qualifier for w4 a break of ZL or would this example be in your options since AO probably reached some-one's yellow minimum.
Q2: Since i do not want to do divergence trading as it's own setup and stay as close to AIMS principles as possible.
I have 3 possible entry scenario's. Your comments?
1. 1st TL break (blue, marked 1) and break+test of balance line.
2. 2nd break of TL and test of purple.
3. Break of aims level, setup 2.
I do realise 1min may have considerable variations because of it's subjected TF, above just guidelines.
No concern required from you, just putting you on the spot, gleaning your insights... :-B .. I take my own decisions.. B-)
Thanks for your valued time.
I am deliberating sending you some vetkoek-on-the-house to speed up the testing..... this chart scanning is making me crazy...

Herbert
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.
Luck = LABOR UNDER CORRECT KNOWLEDGE - Forex Joe
"Nothing wins more than superior research and preparation"
AIMS - The art of Trading markets successfully
"Nothing wins more than superior research and preparation"
AIMS - The art of Trading markets successfully
- Herbert
- Free Member
- Posts: 587
- Joined: 07 Jan 2012, 12:18
- 13
Re: Herbert's trades for discussion
Some additional thought on above post.
As per shown chart, the depicted Ewave 3 on price can of course prompt a larger rounded wave 4 developing to ZL with equally developing wave 5 to follow, which is quite often. There-fore, i take an early entry as per options may put me in a wave 4 trap.... :ymsick:
AIMS qualifiers essential.....
Herbert
As per shown chart, the depicted Ewave 3 on price can of course prompt a larger rounded wave 4 developing to ZL with equally developing wave 5 to follow, which is quite often. There-fore, i take an early entry as per options may put me in a wave 4 trap.... :ymsick:

AIMS qualifiers essential.....
Herbert
Luck = LABOR UNDER CORRECT KNOWLEDGE - Forex Joe
"Nothing wins more than superior research and preparation"
AIMS - The art of Trading markets successfully
"Nothing wins more than superior research and preparation"
AIMS - The art of Trading markets successfully
- snorm
- AIMSter
- Posts: 305
- Joined: 13 Aug 2011, 22:57
- 14
Re: Herbert's trades for discussion
Meneer Herbert
that's a perfect post for the P5 section in the forum - don't worry about cluttering it, such discussions are what it's there for.
Technically that doesn't exactly fit the P5 rules as the eWaves hasn't shown the wave count - it's a P3
Nevertheless, the price-based E count is good and the channel is perfect. The channel would have been the secondary TL; the red line the primary TL. The blue dotted vertical line shows the confirmed break of the secondary TL; 4 bars later you have the re-test of that TL, with balance line test as you say - a perfect bar to place your order under, coinciding with AO cross.
Break of ZL seems to be a great confirmer of the TL break - whilst I have added a ZL cross alert to eWaves, it's not currently part of the W5 alert that I'm working on (it will simply be a W5 alert for now).
All three of your entry scenarios are good - the break of AIMS under 2 would have been a great add-on, as would 3.
Great chart matey and a little less bejazzled than normal (rofl) Could this be the new Herbert template ...???? Still have Mr Demark numbers on there I see - I've never found them to be of any real use so gave up testing them some years back.
Can I have my vetkoek now ????
cheers
Steve :-B
that's a perfect post for the P5 section in the forum - don't worry about cluttering it, such discussions are what it's there for.
Technically that doesn't exactly fit the P5 rules as the eWaves hasn't shown the wave count - it's a P3

Break of ZL seems to be a great confirmer of the TL break - whilst I have added a ZL cross alert to eWaves, it's not currently part of the W5 alert that I'm working on (it will simply be a W5 alert for now).
All three of your entry scenarios are good - the break of AIMS under 2 would have been a great add-on, as would 3.
Great chart matey and a little less bejazzled than normal (rofl) Could this be the new Herbert template ...???? Still have Mr Demark numbers on there I see - I've never found them to be of any real use so gave up testing them some years back.
Can I have my vetkoek now ????
cheers
Steve :-B