$200,000 Forex Funded Account Challenge - Evaluation Phase 2

Start a Trading Journal - Start Posting Your T20 Trades Here.
Tips for First Post: Start with personal introduction, share your story, your future plans.
Use Template Prodvided for Recording Trades.
Post Reply
User avatar
immy
Founder
Founder
Posts: 9654
Joined: 22 Nov 2010, 16:46
14

$200,000 Forex Funded Account Challenge - Evaluation Phase 2

Unread post by immy »

DISCIPLINE AND CONSISTENCY IS THE KEY 

I am keeping this journal and doing the T20 Batches because I have found out that I have lost my way and I am taking the bad trades. I doubt myself and I doubt the setups. I need to be more objective. 

I have become an indiscipline trader so the only way to get good is to keep my journal public again. 

Even after 10 years of trading, you can suddenly become "indisciplined". The only way forward is to get naked and take a bath in public. 

It really is not about showing off (I mean I'm losing, what is there to show aye)... it's about GETTING good and it's about accountability. 

Also, I want to feel like you all. I am no god of trading nor am I that good. I think I am just a mediocre trader. I have stopped m1 and I am only trading the hourly charts now.

In a way, I'm learning new things. There is so much more to trading the hourly charts than I expected. It sure is a lot of fun but for now, I am in a drawdown and that is NOT fun. 

Risk to Reward Ratio is The Secret to Winning in Forex.
The way to win is to ensure you have a trading system with a high reward-to-risk ratio. The 1:5 average win rate is really the sweet spot. 

How to calculate Breakeven Win Rate? 
Very simple Add Risk + Reward and Dived 100 by that figure. 
E.g. Risk is 1% and Reward is 5%. = 100/6 = 16.6% win rate is your Breakeven Winrate. 

Is the probability of Getting 5R always the same for every trade? 
The probability of winning a trade and Win rate are not the same things.

Winrate can change from time to time depending on the PHASE of the Market and your chosen time frame.

When you take a signal with a small stop loss and it appears during a CLEAR trending market then the probability of both a) winning and b) higher reward is HIGH. 

In contrast, if the market is not moving (a tight trading range or overall trend is not present) then the probability of both winning and a higher reward is lower. Worst times to trade. 

If the market is sideways and your stop-loss is wide, then the probability of a win will slightly improve due to a wider stop-loss by the risk to reward will be low (it sucks). 

If the stop loss is TIGHT and it is a trading range, there will be a higher chance of getting stopped out i.e. the win rate will be very low but the risk to reward will be higher compared to a wider stop loss.

Best Times to Trade
But compare this to taking a wider stop loss entry within a trending market or taking a tight stop loss entry within a trending market. I would say the best type of trade is the one with a TIGHT stop loss, (to get bigger lot sizes) and within Clearly Trending Markets (Hot Markets) e.g. markets like the 2nd or 3rd day plays (USDJPY during 2022). The best market for this is the USD/JPY and the Indices. 

The best Risk to Reward Ratio is the 1:5 Concept
As long as stop loss is less than or near 1ATR - 1.2ATR (less than 15 for USDJPY and EURUSD less than 20 for GBPUSD and less than 50 for DAX and NASDAQ) 1:5 is the best target point.

How to Get 1:10 Winners?
The breakeven win rate percentage for 1:10 trades is just 9%. Meaning you only have to win 1 trade within 10 trades to remain breakeven. In effect if you only win 3 times within 20 trades, you will still be in profit.

How to Get 10R Winners on USD/JPY?
The way to hit 10R winners on USDJPY is to always go for 10R targets when you get a seed or banana signal with a stop loss 10 pips or lower.

USDJPY has an ADR of around 100 pips. It can drop to 70 at times but recently as of June 2022, it stands at 135. This means that if you catch a 10 pips stop loss trade and it continues in the direction of the Daily time frame trend, you are highly likely to see a 70-150 pips move within today and the next day. In this case, you will hit your 10R target nicely. If stop loss is 20 then best to stick to 5R because you need 100 pips to move to get 5R and 200 pips for a 10R. It's not always possible to catch 200 peppers on USDJPY. 

You can catch 200 pip winners on US30 all the time right? but there is a problem. You need around 100 pips to stop loss for US30 (DJIA). So to catch a 10R winner on US30 (DOW) is to catch trades that require 50 pips or less stop loss. Then you can expect to hit 5 to 10 R targets relatively easily within today and the next day. 


What is my Trading Time Frame? 
H1 Only


What is my Risk Per Trade? (Account Size $350,000)

If the Balance is above 0 then the Risk Per Trade is 1.0%

Drawdown Protection:

If the Balance is below 2% then 0.5% Risk Per Trade. 
If the Balance is below -2% then 0.25% Risk Per Trade. 


Positive Balance Advantage:
If the Balance is above 3%  then 1.5% Risk Per Trade.
If the Balance is above 5%  then 2% Risk Per Trade. 


What are my Entry Setups:
Banana Signals within the following context
  1. Signal after A Clean Fresh Breakout of Tight Trading Range (No clear trend already in place)
  2. Banana Signal After a Breakout of Consolidation on a 2nd or 3rd Day of trend. (Clear Trend previous day)
The FO Open Line Filter: 
As long as there is a valid signal
BUY Only when the Entry Level for the Banana or Seed Signal is above the Frankfurt Open Price and
SELL Only when the Entry Level for the Banana or Seed Signal is below the Frankfurt Open Price
Edited: 26 June 2022

https://witeboard.com/2dd83b10-e7e7-11e ... 34ae32cb11

Example of 2nd and 3rd Day Plays within a TREND
Trade 1 - USDJPY 6R.jpg
 
2nd and 3rd day plays.jpg
 

Trade Management: 

Target is always set at 5R (at least)
Move SL to BE at +2R

Max Stop Loss Guide

EU Max SL 25(ish)
GU MAx 30(ish)
UJ MAx 20
DAX Max 50
US30 100
NASDAQ 50


What Markets Do I trade:
Update: 23 June 2022
6 Markets - EU GU UJ DAX (US30 and NAS100)
4 Markets are Enough.jpg
 

What is my Template:
5/10 ema and Banana Signals


Will I Take Trades on H4?
NO, I have changed my mind on this because H4 is making me flick and switch too much. I don't need to do that.  I will stick to H1 signals. That's more than enough. (Updated 8 June 2022).

Will I Take Trades on M5 based on H1?
Yes, if I don't get an entry on H1 and the trend is clear I will try to get an M5/H1 entry but only with a quarter risk per trade. 

What is the Ideal Number of Impulse Candles I look for? 

The impulse wave can consist of a minimum of 2 and a max of 5 candles. Within this impulse, we can see a variety of formations from 2 trend candles to up to 4 trend candles. 2 to 3 Trend Candles are the best combination. 
I Want to See 
  • TTTPPP
  • TTTPP
  • TTTP
  • TTPPP
  • TTPP
  • TTP
  • TP
I Don't want to trade 
  • TRP
  • TRRP
  • TRTR 
  • TTRRP
  • CRPP
  • CC (Climactic Candles)  
I Don't want to trade inside H1 Trading Ranges. 
Do not Trade Trading Ranges.jpg
 

I want to Trade within Trends. 
Trade Trending Markets.jpg
What is the Current/Short term TREND? 
When Price (close) is above the dashed line and the dashed line is above the solid line = UPTREND (short term)
When Price (close) is below the dashed line and the dashed line is below the solid line = DOWN TREND (Short term) 

What is the Longer Term Trend?
Same as above but on the Daily Time Frame (the Next Higher Time Frame) 

or

If the Short Term Trend is above or below 50ema.  

What is the Ideal Number of pullback Candles I look for? 
I look for 2 to 4 small pullback candles and signals

Will I trade the Waltz Signal on H1?
Yes, The waltz must have a clear TC followed by 1 or 2 seeds. The Waltz must be a setup after a TTR. 



 My Process Flowchart 
BFC2.jpg
 

PAY ATTENTION TO DAILY CANDLE HIGHS AND LOWS ... VERY POWERFUL 

My favourite Pattern is TTTPP or TTP or TTPP 

 
 Index of Batches: Link to another Topic
 
 
Last Update:

11 July 2022: Trend Definition Added 
26 June 2022: FO Open Price Filter
23 June 2022
 
 Attachements: 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.
What is the Secret of Successful Trading?
The Consistent Pursuit of DS1 :nerd

The thing that makes me money in trading is when I "Objectively Follow my Trading Plan".

I understand that I can't catch all the moves or all the signals but my objective is to catch THE VALID SIGNALS & ONLY the Valid Signals.

My Deathbed Advice "5:1 Reward to Risk Ratio".

Yo, banana boy! 🍌
User avatar
immy
Founder
Founder
Posts: 9654
Joined: 22 Nov 2010, 16:46
14

Evaluation Phase 2 - Batch 1 Trade 1-20 and Batch 2 - Trade 4,5,6,7

Unread post by immy »

Evaluation Phase 2 -

All Trades from Batch 1 and Batch 2 

Editing this on the 3rd of July: 
Evaluation Phase 1: All Trades 3 Batches Posted in this Topic Click Here

Batch 1.
This Batch started as the WORST trading batch of my life, or perhaps the history of trading. So Ashamed I could not share it until today. Iit  will share it with you. I lost my marbles. I completely lost it. I thought I was the God of trading (not really). I was confident and then this happened. completely insane. No risk parameters, no entry rules, absolute chaos. 

I'm going to share my comments and screenshots that were never intended for sharing. So please forgive the f**** words. 

Trade 1 
Comment from my Journal: 
This is a disgrace I started with a BAD trade. there were levels to the left, and there was no clean impulse.
B1T1.png
Trade 2
Comment from my Journal: feck this shit = MUST JOURNAL EVERY NIGHT
B1T2.png
Trade 3
Comment from my Journal: OMG I started this shit again and I did not even KNOW
B1T3.png
 
Trade 4
Comment from my Journal
B1T4.png
 
Trade 5 
Comment from my Journal
B1T5.png
 
Trade 6 
Comment from my Journal
B1T6.png
 
Trade 7 
Comment from my Journal: This was a signal and I should not have exited. Had I journaled this I'd have realised my mistake and corrected it. I must Journal every day. I must journal everyday, record my thoughts and comments and analyse my performance. 
B1T7.png
 
Trade 8 
Comment from my Journal: This should have been my first trade. And a full 1% Loss. my account would be at the same stage. DS1
B1T8.png
 
Trade 9 
Comment from my Journal: This is the signal. Keep taking these DS1
B1T9.png
 
Trade 10
Comment from my Journal: Keep taking these ones. DS1
B1T10.png
 
Trade 11
Comment from my Journal
B1T11.png
 
Trade 12
Comment from my Journal
B1T12.png
 
Trade 13
Comment from my Journal
B1T13.png
 
Trade 14
Comment from my Journal
B1T14.png
 
Trade 15
Comment from my Journal
B1T15.png
 
Trade 16 
Comment from my Journal: I was fucking around with the GU trade and later realised my mistake so I got back in. Had I taken the signal with 3R target, it was HIT. Minsk took it and hit 3R.
B1T16.png
 Trade 17
Comment from my Journal; I can't believe my eyes when I am looking at this journal and this batch. Look at me. I Promised I will journal DAILY
B1T17.png
 
Trade 18
Comment from my Journal
B1T18.png
 
Trade 19
No Trade Recorded, Abandoned this batch due to 0% Discipline Score

Trade 20

Total DS: 3/17 = 17% (Absolutely nightmare - Be humble and accept that you don't know shit. You are still a baby, Johnny, you're such a baby, grow the f*** up)

Batch 2: 

Trade 1: Ah well, AUD/USD It was a DS1 nothing wrong NEXT 
B2T1.png
Trade 1 - Re-entry small lot.png
Trade 1 - DS1.png
Trade 2: I am NOT going to trade these again. This just "ruins" my mindset. I know I'm good at it, but it just messes with my process of looking for Banana Signals. 
B2T2.png
Trade 2.png
 
Trade 3: A good signal, not too bad. DS 1
B2T3.png
Trade 3 DAX DS1 -1.png
 

 Trade 4: 
Trader 4 - NAS Ds1 -0.5.png
 
Trade 5
Trade 5 - US30 DS0 no signal.png
 Trade 6
Trade 6 - USDJPY DS1 but low quality setup.png
 Trade 7 
Trade 7 - UK100 DS0.png
 
Review: Too many trades? nah, its ok. My risk was capped at max 1.25%. I am down 1.25% today. That's fine, nothing wrong with it. I will recover this in one trade. I know it. 
 
Trade 8: 

 
 Trade 9: 

Trade 10: 

Trade 11: 

Trade 12: 

Trade 13: 

Trade 14: 

Trade 15: 

Trade 16:

Trade 17: 

Trade 18:

Trade 19:

Trade 20: 



 
 
 
 
 
 
 
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.
What is the Secret of Successful Trading?
The Consistent Pursuit of DS1 :nerd

The thing that makes me money in trading is when I "Objectively Follow my Trading Plan".

I understand that I can't catch all the moves or all the signals but my objective is to catch THE VALID SIGNALS & ONLY the Valid Signals.

My Deathbed Advice "5:1 Reward to Risk Ratio".

Yo, banana boy! 🍌
User avatar
tombacon89
AIMSter
AIMSter
Posts: 384
Joined: 05 Feb 2012, 18:26
13

Re: Invitation to Everyone to CRITICISE and Challenge Me

Unread post by tombacon89 »

Thankyou immy for allowing yourself to be vulnerable with us. It’s important. I hope this bring you back where you need to be; I also hope that other people’s scrutiny helps themselves understand the setup deeper; and brings more confidence.  

Trade 5. I see no signal. No signal no trade 😌…. I now see it was not the bannana setup but a short trade Anyway, was not a bannana for me 😊

  Ps. I know there is a caveat to that when you KNOW it should be a signal. I had a no signal today too even though I knew it was 100% a signal. V14.2. Emma had the signal.  😊 
 
 
'Do Not let yourself get in the way of your profit producing tools'

"If it’s meant to be, the universe is gonna throw it back to me, to get it back all we need is to let it go, put your faith put your trust in the chemicals" - Various Cruelties - Chemicals
User avatar
immy
Founder
Founder
Posts: 9654
Joined: 22 Nov 2010, 16:46
14

Re: Immy's Journal - Reborn

Unread post by immy »

kvr1966 wrote: 23 May 2022, 19:34 I suppose DS1 is hard for anyone. Experienced or not.
I learn from everybody's journals, thank you for sharing yours.

 
Hi 

Yes, for me its always been hard because I have an adhd and creative mind. I keep inventing stuff and keep testing new things. That's good and bad. So the T20 process keeps me check. Journaling, which I have always done offline, detailed journalling, keeps me on track. If there is ever a period of a week or so that i don't meticulously record everything, I begin to go off the track. When I finally catch up on journaling I swear at myself and do all sorts of things. 

:) 
What is the Secret of Successful Trading?
The Consistent Pursuit of DS1 :nerd

The thing that makes me money in trading is when I "Objectively Follow my Trading Plan".

I understand that I can't catch all the moves or all the signals but my objective is to catch THE VALID SIGNALS & ONLY the Valid Signals.

My Deathbed Advice "5:1 Reward to Risk Ratio".

Yo, banana boy! 🍌
User avatar
immy
Founder
Founder
Posts: 9654
Joined: 22 Nov 2010, 16:46
14

Re: Invitation to Everyone to CRITICISE and Challenge Me

Unread post by immy »

tombacon89 wrote: 23 May 2022, 18:01 Thankyou immy for allowing yourself to be vulnerable with us. It’s important. I hope this bring you back where you need to be; I also hope that other people’s scrutiny helps themselves understand the setup deeper; and brings more confidence.  

Trade 5. I see no signal. No signal no trade 😌…. I now see it was not the bannana setup but a short trade Anyway, was not a bannana for me 😊

  Ps. I know there is a caveat to that when you KNOW it should be a signal. I had a no signal today too even though I knew it was 100% a signal. V14.2. Emma had the signal.  😊 
 
 


 
Thank you Tom 

I thought, why not join the team! I have abandoned my other (offline) journal after 10 years. I will journal here. So that I am part of the group! I will continue to keep my sheet of recording trades off line but i will share the pictures and thoughts here. 

cheers 

ps: Trade 5, yeah I know right... (I was going short NAS and DAX thought take a position on this thing too. to make it 1% in total) All 3 failed. The one I did not take, EU hit 3R :)  :pray:
  
 
 
What is the Secret of Successful Trading?
The Consistent Pursuit of DS1 :nerd

The thing that makes me money in trading is when I "Objectively Follow my Trading Plan".

I understand that I can't catch all the moves or all the signals but my objective is to catch THE VALID SIGNALS & ONLY the Valid Signals.

My Deathbed Advice "5:1 Reward to Risk Ratio".

Yo, banana boy! 🍌
User avatar
immy
Founder
Founder
Posts: 9654
Joined: 22 Nov 2010, 16:46
14

The End of M1

Unread post by immy »

Hi 

I love trading the m1 charts but it was a long term plan of mine to one day stop trading the m1 charts. 

I have now completely abandoned trading the M1 charts. I am so bored and yet so relaxed. Boredom is filled with reading books and chatting with people over the phone. 

Boredom seems to be a powerful thing. It can sometimes lead to creativity. LEt's see how it goes 

:rock
 
What is the Secret of Successful Trading?
The Consistent Pursuit of DS1 :nerd

The thing that makes me money in trading is when I "Objectively Follow my Trading Plan".

I understand that I can't catch all the moves or all the signals but my objective is to catch THE VALID SIGNALS & ONLY the Valid Signals.

My Deathbed Advice "5:1 Reward to Risk Ratio".

Yo, banana boy! 🍌
User avatar
immy
Founder
Founder
Posts: 9654
Joined: 22 Nov 2010, 16:46
14

Trade 8 GBP/USD Trade 9 UJ Trade 10 GJ

Unread post by immy »

Trade 8,9 and 10 were taken off the same setup. 

The Pound was showing a sell setup so was GJ and UJ. 

I went half risk on GJ, quarter on GU and Quarter on UJ


Then It was evident that GU was being held by the previous Range. I exited that and let GJ and UJ Run. 

I then Exited UJ at 3R and Exited GJ at 2R. 

GJ exit 2R due to Levels to the left. I'm done for the DAY 


 
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.
What is the Secret of Successful Trading?
The Consistent Pursuit of DS1 :nerd

The thing that makes me money in trading is when I "Objectively Follow my Trading Plan".

I understand that I can't catch all the moves or all the signals but my objective is to catch THE VALID SIGNALS & ONLY the Valid Signals.

My Deathbed Advice "5:1 Reward to Risk Ratio".

Yo, banana boy! 🍌
User avatar
immy
Founder
Founder
Posts: 9654
Joined: 22 Nov 2010, 16:46
14

Trade 11 - NASDAQ Number 5

Unread post by immy »

I took this trade simply because it was a signal. NAsdaq was not bullish, but not really bearish either. It was Trading Range 

I took just baby lots. Great winner. 
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.
What is the Secret of Successful Trading?
The Consistent Pursuit of DS1 :nerd

The thing that makes me money in trading is when I "Objectively Follow my Trading Plan".

I understand that I can't catch all the moves or all the signals but my objective is to catch THE VALID SIGNALS & ONLY the Valid Signals.

My Deathbed Advice "5:1 Reward to Risk Ratio".

Yo, banana boy! 🍌
User avatar
Minsk
AIMSter
AIMSter
Posts: 498
Joined: 11 Nov 2021, 16:11
3

Re: Trade 11 - NASDAQ Number 5

Unread post by Minsk »

immy wrote: 24 May 2022, 15:19 I took this trade simply because it was a signal. NAsdaq was not bullish, but not really bearish either. It was Trading Range 

I took just baby lots. Great winner. 

 
:party
 that is a profit!
User avatar
immy
Founder
Founder
Posts: 9654
Joined: 22 Nov 2010, 16:46
14

Review 25 May 2022

Unread post by immy »

What is the Secret of Successful Trading?
The Consistent Pursuit of DS1 :nerd

The thing that makes me money in trading is when I "Objectively Follow my Trading Plan".

I understand that I can't catch all the moves or all the signals but my objective is to catch THE VALID SIGNALS & ONLY the Valid Signals.

My Deathbed Advice "5:1 Reward to Risk Ratio".

Yo, banana boy! 🍌
Post Reply